Another guest
post by Macronomics, this time on
how, when and why to recap the banks.
You can get update notifications by
following MoreLiver on Twitter or Facebook. Contact me with any questions or
suggestions.
Previously
on MoreLiver (the Calendar-page has been updated as well):
5th May - Weekender: Elections (updated)
Credit - Peripheral Banks, Kneecap Recap.
"That's the method: restructure the world we live in in some way, then see what happens." - Frederik Pohl
We already touched at length in our past credit conversations on the liability exercise management taken by many weaker peripheral banks in relation to raising capital to reach the 9% Core Tier 1 Capital target set up by the European Banking Association for June 2012 (see our conversations "Subordinated debt - Love me tender?" and "Goodwill Hunting Redux"):
"First bond tenders, then we will probably see debt to equity swaps for weaker peripheral banks with no access to term funding, leading to significant losses for subordinate bondholders as well as dilution for shareholders in the process." - Macronomics - 20th of November 2011.
In 2011 as well as very recently, bond tenders have been a recurring theme in the credit space.
As a reminder on bond tenders:
Debt tender offer:
"When a firm retires all or a portion of its debt securities by making an offer to its debt holders to repurchase a predetermined number of bonds at a specified price and during a set period of time. Firms may use a debt tender offer as a mechanism for capital restructuring or refinancing."
We believe additional debt to equity swaps will have to happen for weaker peripheral banks, similar to what we witnessed with Banco Espirito Santo in October 2011, as well as for German bank Commerzbank ("Schedule Chicken" - 25th of February 2012).
We wrote in October 2011 relating to bond tenders and the move towards debt to equity swap:
"We expected others to follow suit and given the difficulty for the weaker players in the peripheral space to access capital at a reasonable rate, as well as needing to boost their core Tier 1 capital base, it was of no surprise to see Portuguese bank Banco Espirito Santo following French bank BPCE in tendering some of its subordinated debt on the 18th of October, but this time around, we have a debt to equity swap."
Banco Espirito Santo stock price evolution - source Bloomberg:
All clear for Banco Espirito Santo, but definitely not for its Portuguese peer, Banco Comercial Português (BCP):
"Banco Comercial Português has yet to give details of how it will cover a shortfall of €2.1 bln identified by the EBA. There is a €12 bln government recapitalisation facility available to Portuguese banks under the bailout package." - CreditSights - Euro Bank Capital Model FY11: We Are The 9%, 2nd of May 2012.
When it comes to BCP, a debt to equity swap could be a solution if we take a look at the stock price - source Bloomberg:
Not pretty to say the least...
When it comes to Greek banks, they are in the front line (see our post "Liquidity? The IV Greek Credit Therapy").
Lack of capital follows the results of the Greek PSI, leaving them with dire needs as indicated by Marcus Bensasson, Maria Petrakis and Natalie Weeks
in their article on Bloomberg on the 20th of April - Top Greek Banks Post $37 Billion in Losses on Debt Restructuring:
And the Bloomberg article to add:
"National Bank, the nation’s biggest lender, had a net loss of 12.3 billion euros for 2011 after a 406 million-euro profit a year earlier, the Athens-based lender said in a statement today. The average estimate from three analysts surveyed by Bloomberg News was for a loss of 9.29 billion euros.
EFG Eurobank Ergasias SA, the second-biggest lender, had a 5.51 billion-euro loss after a 68 million-euro profit in 2010 and Alpha Bank SA, the third biggest, lost 3.81 billion euros after an 86 million-euro profit in 2010. Piraeus Bank SA, the fourth largest, had a 6.3 billion-euro loss.
National Bank took 10.8 billion euros of post-tax impairments on Greek government bond holdings after writing down their value by 75 percent. Eurobank wrote down 4.6 billion euros of government bonds after taxes and Alpha Bank 3.8 billion euros. Piraeus wrote down 5.1 billion euros."
Another nice job done by "analysts"...
So, no surprise for us to hear recently about the bond tender exercise being followed by Greek bank Alpha Group Limited:
For similar purposes as all other bond tenders we have seen so far, namely to boost Core Tier 1 Capital:
Alpha Bank stock price - 24th of April 2012 - source Bloomberg:
ASE - Greek stock index evolution - 24th of April - source Bloomberg:
From our conversation "Equities, there's life (and value) after default!", we know that the outstanding weight of "Financials" in the ASE Greek index, is roughly around 21.70%. We wrote at the time:
The same Bloomberg article also indicated the following in relation to Greek Banks Core Tier 1 ratios:
When it comes to rising pressure in relation to the need for fresh capital, it could not be more truer given the significant rise in non-performing loans as reported by Bloomberg on the 4th of May:
"Greek banks collectively saw the level of non-performing loans rise to 17 percent of their total loan portfolio at the end of the first quarter from 14.7 percent at the end of the third quarter of 2011, Kathimerini reported.
Bad mortgages climbed to 16 percent of the total, or 12.5 billion euros ($16.4 billion), from 14 percent, the Athens-based newspaper said today, citing Greek banking officials. Bad consumer loans increased to 29 percent, or 9.6 billion euros, from 26.4 percent and bad business loans nose to 15 percent, or 18 billion euros, from 13 percent, it said." - source Bloomberg, Paul Tugwell.
So what is the plan for Greek banks? So far no plan...
The HFSF (Hellenic Financial Stability Facility) total 13 billion, 1.3 billion for Alpha Bank, 4.2 billion for EFG Eurobank, 6.9 billion for National Bank of Greece (who had the largest holding of Greek bonds on its balance sheet). According to CrediSights, these facilities allow the banks to report total capital ratios of at least 8% under the current EU Capital Adequacy Directive, which in turn makes them "officially solvent" and therefore "eligible" for ECB funding...
Looking at the outcome from the Greek elections on the 6th of May with the losses of pro-austerity parties, it spells trouble ahead for Greece and its ailing financial system, resorting to desperation tactics like
-suing Reuters News agency:
"Greek bank sues Reuters over investigative report" - Reuters, 2nd of May.
We already touched at length in our past credit conversations on the liability exercise management taken by many weaker peripheral banks in relation to raising capital to reach the 9% Core Tier 1 Capital target set up by the European Banking Association for June 2012 (see our conversations "Subordinated debt - Love me tender?" and "Goodwill Hunting Redux"):
"First bond tenders, then we will probably see debt to equity swaps for weaker peripheral banks with no access to term funding, leading to significant losses for subordinate bondholders as well as dilution for shareholders in the process." - Macronomics - 20th of November 2011.
In 2011 as well as very recently, bond tenders have been a recurring theme in the credit space.
As a reminder on bond tenders:
Debt tender offer:
"When a firm retires all or a portion of its debt securities by making an offer to its debt holders to repurchase a predetermined number of bonds at a specified price and during a set period of time. Firms may use a debt tender offer as a mechanism for capital restructuring or refinancing."
We believe additional debt to equity swaps will have to happen for weaker peripheral banks, similar to what we witnessed with Banco Espirito Santo in October 2011, as well as for German bank Commerzbank ("Schedule Chicken" - 25th of February 2012).
We wrote in October 2011 relating to bond tenders and the move towards debt to equity swap:
"We expected others to follow suit and given the difficulty for the weaker players in the peripheral space to access capital at a reasonable rate, as well as needing to boost their core Tier 1 capital base, it was of no surprise to see Portuguese bank Banco Espirito Santo following French bank BPCE in tendering some of its subordinated debt on the 18th of October, but this time around, we have a debt to equity swap."
Banco Espirito Santo stock price evolution - source Bloomberg:
Survival
of the fittest...On October 18 Banco Espirito Santo announced a capital
increase in effect via its bond tender which meant at the time a 83.5%
dilution for shareholders. This was followed by another capital increase
of 1 billion euro announced mid-April, to be completed by early May
(see our conversation "All Quiet on the Western Front").
According to recent note by CreditSights (Euro Financial Movers - Walking on Eggshells - 15th of April 2012):
"Unnamed major shareholders have
committed to subscribe just over half of the amount (50.63%), and the
remainder is underwritten by a syndicate of banks. On an FY11 pro-forma
basis, this will take BES's Core Tier 1 ratio to over 10.5% and allow it
to meet the EBA's end-June requirement of 9 Core Tier 1. The
consolidated EBA shortfall for BES's parent, Espirito Santo Financial
Group, is €1,597 mln."
All clear for Banco Espirito Santo, but definitely not for its Portuguese peer, Banco Comercial Português (BCP):
"Banco Comercial Português has yet to give details of how it will cover a shortfall of €2.1 bln identified by the EBA. There is a €12 bln government recapitalisation facility available to Portuguese banks under the bailout package." - CreditSights - Euro Bank Capital Model FY11: We Are The 9%, 2nd of May 2012.
When it comes to BCP, a debt to equity swap could be a solution if we take a look at the stock price - source Bloomberg:
When it comes to Greek banks, they are in the front line (see our post "Liquidity? The IV Greek Credit Therapy").
Lack of capital follows the results of the Greek PSI, leaving them with dire needs as indicated by Marcus Bensasson, Maria Petrakis and Natalie Weeks
in their article on Bloomberg on the 20th of April - Top Greek Banks Post $37 Billion in Losses on Debt Restructuring:
Greece’s four biggest banks
reported a combined loss of 27.9 billion euros ($36.9 billion) for last
year after participating in the country’s debt exchange, the largest
sovereign restructuring in history.
The
four, including National Bank of Greece, EFG Eurobank Ergasias SA,
Alpha Bank SA and Piraeus Bank SA, said they wrote down about 25 billion
euros in the combined value of their Greek government bond holdings.
Prime
Minister Lucas Papademos is trying to finalize a plan to recapitalize
Greek banks, which wrote down more than half the face value of their
government bonds and posted an increase in bad loan ratios after five
years of recession. Greece’s bank-recapitalization body yesterday got 25
billion euros in a first tranche of funds, or half the total assigned
for the purpose, as part of a second bailout by the European Union and
International Monetary Fund."
And the Bloomberg article to add:
"National Bank, the nation’s biggest lender, had a net loss of 12.3 billion euros for 2011 after a 406 million-euro profit a year earlier, the Athens-based lender said in a statement today. The average estimate from three analysts surveyed by Bloomberg News was for a loss of 9.29 billion euros.
EFG Eurobank Ergasias SA, the second-biggest lender, had a 5.51 billion-euro loss after a 68 million-euro profit in 2010 and Alpha Bank SA, the third biggest, lost 3.81 billion euros after an 86 million-euro profit in 2010. Piraeus Bank SA, the fourth largest, had a 6.3 billion-euro loss.
National Bank took 10.8 billion euros of post-tax impairments on Greek government bond holdings after writing down their value by 75 percent. Eurobank wrote down 4.6 billion euros of government bonds after taxes and Alpha Bank 3.8 billion euros. Piraeus wrote down 5.1 billion euros."
Another nice job done by "analysts"...
So, no surprise for us to hear recently about the bond tender exercise being followed by Greek bank Alpha Group Limited:
"Alpha Group Limited (the
"Offeror"), a member of the Alpha Bank A.E. group (the "Group) announced
today tender offers (the "Offers")for Any and All of two Tier One
Securities, one Upper Tier II Security and two Lower Tier II Securities
("Securities") with an aggregate face amount outstanding of
approximately EUR 985mm."
For similar purposes as all other bond tenders we have seen so far, namely to boost Core Tier 1 Capital:
"The purpose of the Offers is to
generate Core Tier One capital for the Group and to strengthen the
quality of its capital base. If completed, the Offers would generate a
gain for the Group and thereby increase Core Tier One capital. The
Offers also provide investors with an opportunity to monetise their
investments at the relevant Purchase Price."
Opportunity for the bondholders to "get to the exit while they can" and take their losses...
Alpha
Bank SA offered to buy back a nominal 1.58 billion euros of outstanding
securities in a bid to boost its capital. If completed, this offer
would generate a gain for the group’s Core Tier 1 capital, which the
bank reported at 3 percent for 2011 according to Bloomberg, when the
target is 9% for June 2012 for European banks as required by the
European Banking Association plan but, for Greek Banks, they have until September 2012 for achieving the 9% required.
In 2011, during the last EBA stress tests for European banks, 30
billion was assigned to Greece's banking system out of the 115 billion
original EU-wide bailout plan.
Alpha Bank stock price - 24th of April 2012 - source Bloomberg:
ASE - Greek stock index evolution - 24th of April - source Bloomberg:
"Given the outstanding weight of
financials in the Greek ASE index and knowing their current Greek debt
holdings, Alpha Bank, National Bank of Greece, EFG Eurobank and Piraeus
bank respective equity is probably worth zero. It should in theory
equate to an additional write down of at least 16.74% of the ASE Greek
index."
The same Bloomberg article also indicated the following in relation to Greek Banks Core Tier 1 ratios:
"National Bank, Eurobank
and Piraeus Bank did not disclose what their Core Tier 1 ratios would be
without support from the Hellenic Financial Stability Fund, the state
recapitalization body. National Bank reported a Core Tier 1 capital ratio of 6.3 percent after an injection of 6.9 billion euros from the HFSF.
Agricultural
Bank of Greece SA and TT Hellenic Postbank SA, two state controlled
lenders, were granted extensions and will report earnings by May 31, the banks said in exchange filings.
The
bank recapitalization plan includes incentives for private investment
such as rights for shareholders to purchase the government’s stake and
safeguards for buyers of convertible bonds, according an IMF
report released March 16. The HFSF will continue to hold voting rights
in the event of strategic decisions related to the banks to avert the
risk of asset stripping by investment funds, according to the report."
When it comes to rising pressure in relation to the need for fresh capital, it could not be more truer given the significant rise in non-performing loans as reported by Bloomberg on the 4th of May:
"Greek banks collectively saw the level of non-performing loans rise to 17 percent of their total loan portfolio at the end of the first quarter from 14.7 percent at the end of the third quarter of 2011, Kathimerini reported.
Bad mortgages climbed to 16 percent of the total, or 12.5 billion euros ($16.4 billion), from 14 percent, the Athens-based newspaper said today, citing Greek banking officials. Bad consumer loans increased to 29 percent, or 9.6 billion euros, from 26.4 percent and bad business loans nose to 15 percent, or 18 billion euros, from 13 percent, it said." - source Bloomberg, Paul Tugwell.
So what is the plan for Greek banks? So far no plan...
"Greece’s government has yet to
settle on the final terms to recapitalise the nation’s banks after a 100
billion-euro writedown of sovereign debt, said an official at the
Hellenic Financial Stability Fund.
Agreement still needs to be reached on a number of different issues and this may not occur before May 6 elections,
the official, who declined to be named, said after a meeting in Athens
between Panayotis Thomopoulos, the head of the fund, and Prime Minister
Lucas Papademos.
The
official said he hoped the full 50 billion euros allocated to the fund
wouldn’t need to be used and that an initial 18 billion euros had been
provided to the four biggest Greek banks in the form of commitments." - source Bloomberg, Eleni Chrepa - 24th of April 2012.
The HFSF (Hellenic Financial Stability Facility) total 13 billion, 1.3 billion for Alpha Bank, 4.2 billion for EFG Eurobank, 6.9 billion for National Bank of Greece (who had the largest holding of Greek bonds on its balance sheet). According to CrediSights, these facilities allow the banks to report total capital ratios of at least 8% under the current EU Capital Adequacy Directive, which in turn makes them "officially solvent" and therefore "eligible" for ECB funding...
Looking at the outcome from the Greek elections on the 6th of May with the losses of pro-austerity parties, it spells trouble ahead for Greece and its ailing financial system, resorting to desperation tactics like
-suing Reuters News agency:
"Greek bank sues Reuters over investigative report" - Reuters, 2nd of May.
"One of Greece's biggest banks has
filed a lawsuit against Reuters claiming 50 million euros ($66 million)
in damages over a story that exposed a series of property deals between
the bank and companies run by the family of its executive chairman."
-making desperate appeal for fresh private equity to avoid total shareholder equity wipeout:
"Apostolos
Tamvakakis, chief executive of National Bank of Greece, launched a
last-ditch attempt to fend off a wipeout of private shareholder control,
widely considered inevitable across the banking system as lenders
struggle to absorb losses on their government bond holdings and other
bad debts." - Financial Times, Patrick Jenkins, Banking editor - Greek banks appeal for fresh equity.
We believe debt to equity swaps will likely happen for weaker banks as well as full nationalisation for some.
As our good credit friend said in November 2011:
"The path will be very painful for both shareholders and bondholders."
30% of National Bank of Greece shares are in the hands of foreign investors such as Bank of New York Mellon, BlackRock, Allianz, Pictet, Prudential Financial, Aviva, AXA, HSBC and BBVA, according to Bloomberg data.
"When liberty is taken away by force it can be restored by force. When it is relinquished voluntarily by default it can never be recovered." - Dorothy Thompson
Stay Tuned!We believe debt to equity swaps will likely happen for weaker banks as well as full nationalisation for some.
As our good credit friend said in November 2011:
"The path will be very painful for both shareholders and bondholders."
30% of National Bank of Greece shares are in the hands of foreign investors such as Bank of New York Mellon, BlackRock, Allianz, Pictet, Prudential Financial, Aviva, AXA, HSBC and BBVA, according to Bloomberg data.
"When liberty is taken away by force it can be restored by force. When it is relinquished voluntarily by default it can never be recovered." - Dorothy Thompson